The case of Tian Chua being charged for biting police has finally returned to the focus of the alleged crime-so say reports of a PC at Parliament House. This is what it should be-not the other issue like whether Rm2000.00 constitute a penalty enough to disqualify an MP, Parliamentarian’s privileges etc. This is a positive development as it return to the legal issue rather than let it get confused with political considerations. Earlier there were weird suggestions by the Parliament Lower House Speaker and Deputy Speaker to address the issue with a view to stop by-election: Wan Junaidy the deputy speaker suggested that Chua go to jail for 2 months as a way to evade the Rm2000.00 fine and thereby avoid the disqualification as MP. But by laws the prison term is only applicable when the convicted person cannot afford to pay the penalty -thus the penalty still stand, as noted by Karpal Singh. The Speaker Pandikar Amin suggest that so long that the government side don’t propose a motion to remove Chua then he is all right. This suggestion is most dangerous as it imply that the MP will be continuing only at the mercy of BN! This is certainly questionable from legal perspective as the disqualification based on the fine is automatic. Another aspect of this suggestion is that BN MPs will then never be disqualified since they can use party whip to stop any motion to disqualify their own MP who are convicted and fined no less than RM2000.00. What is a legal issue will then be totally politicised!
Tian Chua might appeal court decision

